Blog

Why Indie and Fragrance Brands Should Pay Attention

The beauty industry might look like it's all shimmer and shine, but behind the scenes, legal battles have taken down even the most iconic names. From ingredient controversies to misleading claims, lawsuits have reshaped the landscape—and for indie and fragrance brands, they offer important lessons.

Take Avon and Ben Nye, for example. These long-standing companies filed for bankruptcy in response to hundreds of lawsuits claiming their talc-based products were contaminated with asbestos. Consumers alleged these products caused cancer, forcing both brands to spend millions in legal fees and settlements. For smaller brands, one lawsuit of this magnitude could mean the end.

Johnson & Johnson is another case study in what happens when trust erodes. Hit with a $45 million judgment over its talc products, the brand faced ongoing questions about ingredient safety and transparency. While J&J is massive enough to weather legal storms, indie brands don’t have that cushion. The message is clear: ingredient safety and transparency must be non-negotiable.

Morphe, once a darling of influencer culture, got hit with a class-action lawsuit over color additives used in its makeup. But before things could progress, its parent company filed for bankruptcy. It’s a reminder that legal battles often expose deeper operational issues. If your brand is growing fast, you need compliance and quality controls to keep pace.

CoverGirl, a staple in many makeup bags, was sued after PFAS “forever chemicals” were discovered in their products—despite being marketed as sustainable. It’s a warning shot for brands using terms like “clean” or “green” without the data to back it up. Consumers are watching, regulators are catching up, and lawsuits are becoming a way to enforce accountability. In fact, our deep dive into microplastics and their impact on scent shows how even trace elements in a product can change perception and performance.

Even internal conflict can turn into a PR and legal nightmare. UOMA Beauty saw its operations disrupted after its founder filed a lawsuit against the brand’s new owners, alleging fraudulent business practices. What followed was chaos: customer complaints, shipping delays, and a hit to brand credibility. No matter how beautiful the packaging, legal instability behind the scenes always shows.

While fragrance brands haven’t seen the same volume of public lawsuits, that doesn’t mean they’re in the clear. In fact, the lack of legal attention may just be a temporary lull. Allergic reactions, improper labeling, and vague claims like “non-toxic” or “natural” could all become future battlegrounds. As consumer awareness grows, so will scrutiny. That’s why indie beauty brands have to balance creative freedom with operational risks if they want to grow without stumbling.

For indie fragrance founders, the takeaway is simple. Vet every supplier. Be precise in your messaging. Avoid language you can’t defend. Invest in legal advice early, not after something goes wrong. And if you’re claiming your product is clean, sustainable, or hypoallergenic—be ready to prove it.

Trust and storytelling are at the heart of the beauty business. Fragrance isn't just about scent—it’s about how a person feels when they wear it. Perfume is often part of someone’s self-care routine, which makes customer trust in your product even more sacred. They’re not just buying a product—they’re inviting your brand into their most personal rituals. That makes every decision behind the scenes matter.

Because protecting your brand isn't just about great product and storytelling—it’s about the foundation you build it on. If you’re ready to build something lasting, let these legal lessons be your blueprint. You don’t just want to create something beautiful. You want to create something unshakable.